How this calculator works
Every plan Shopify sells has a public monthly price. What the pricing page doesn’t show clearly is the transaction economics underneath — the payment card rate, the extra fee for using a third-party gateway, and the point at which Shopify Plus starts paying for itself in saved fees before you even count the Plus-only features.
This calculator pulls the published rates from Shopify’s own pricing page and applies them to your monthly GMV + order count. Numbers are directional — Plus card rates in particular are negotiated per contract, so the Plus row uses a conservative estimate. Get the actual number in writing before you sign anything.
The card rate math nobody explains
Shopify Payments card rates vary by plan. As of 2026:
- Basic: 2.9% + 30¢ per online transaction
- Grow: 2.7% + 30¢ per online transaction
- Advanced: 2.5% + 30¢ per online transaction
- Plus: negotiated (typically below Advanced)
A brand doing $2M/year on Advanced with Shopify Payments pays roughly $50,000-$60,000/year in card processing. Move to Plus and that number typically drops $6K-$10K. That’s the payment-side saving before you touch the feature differences. Full breakdown is in the Is Shopify Plus Worth It playbook.
The third-party gateway penalty
If you don’t use Shopify Payments and instead run Stripe, Braintree, PayPal Advanced, etc., Shopify charges an extra transaction fee per order on top of what your gateway charges:
- Basic: 2.0% per transaction
- Grow: 1.0% per transaction
- Advanced: 0.5% per transaction
- Plus: typically 0.15%-0.20% per transaction
This penalty is the single biggest reason merchants move to Shopify Payments where their region supports it. On $2M/year with a third-party gateway you’re paying an extra $10K/year on Advanced that vanishes if you switch to Shopify Payments — before any plan upgrade.
When Plus starts paying for itself
The rule of thumb across the Plus builds I’ve shipped: Plus pays for itself in saved transaction fees alone somewhere between $2M and $4M annual GMV, depending on your gateway setup. Below $2M ARR, the fee savings usually don’t cover the $23K annual Plus premium unless you also need B2B on Shopify, checkout customization beyond Advanced, or API rate limits that only Plus provides.
The full four-threshold framework (revenue, API, B2B, checkout) is in the Plus worth-it playbook. If you want a specialist to actually run these numbers against your specific stack and give a straight answer, book a Plus scoping call.